Him: I’m so sorry about being so terrible at communicating, I severely lack your direct communication skills. The situation is someone I started seeing asked for something more serious with me recently, and asked to make things monogamous, and I decided to give it a go. I know I should’ve said this sooner, but I wasn’t sure for a while and honestly felt sad at the idea of closing the door on what we had. I really appreciate you both in terms of our intamacy and our friendship. But I think this could be a good path for me to try, I think some stability could be good for me. I really hope you are well and the new job is not weighing on you too much.
Me: What? I’ve always wanted to have something serious and monogamous with you and you’ve told me I’m exactly your type and you would absolutely want to be in a relationship with me if you wanted that in general but you don’t want that with anyone because you’re moving to America and you don’t really know what you want in life and don’t want to commit to a relationship. I can’t believe what I just read. I thought you were trustworthy but apparently you lied to me.
Him: I was avoidant before because I was worried I would upset you, but then I reasoned with myself and thought that was me being dumb again I thought you told me that you would never date someone who was leaving the country. I asked you to dinner once and you said we don’t do that. I hate upsetting people and really didn’t mean to hear, it sounds like the communication wasn’t as good as I thought and I don’t understand somethings. I don’t think untrustworthy is fair but I am really sorry to hear that you are hurt.
Me: So your new girlfriend is moving to America with you? Ofc I’m not ok to have a relationship with someone who’s going to move abroad and stay there for who knows how many years but as I wrote you said that’s why you also don’t want to have a relationship in Finland. Apparently you do now which is very surprising.
Him: I am really confused and surprised. I am sorry for any part I played with bad understanding and not reading between the lines, but I’ve always thought that you were very clear from the beggining that anything more than sex dates was not on the cards for us. It is true that serious or monogamy were not things on my emotional radar at all, but after a bout of pretty bad depression, I met someone who after I laid out who and where I am in life, and they still said that they wanted try a deeper monogamous connection. I don’t know what it means but I have felt happier with steady and constant affection, and decided to give it a try. I thought your reaction would be more like the precedent of how I responded to you when you texted to say you had a boyfriend. I hate confrontation so much, I am sure I have made blunders here, but I genuinely had no intention of causing any pain or anger.
Me: You’ve always known my biggest dream is to have a serious relationship and that I didn’t want to have dinner with you because you had made clear you don’t want to be anyone’s boyfriend and I tried to protect myself because I’ve had so many disappointments in life falling for someone and then being rejected. You’ve told me about your depression and who and where you are in life and I’ve still been there for you and kept hoping maybe you fall in love with me so strongly that you decide to stay in Finland after all. You didn’t answer my question if your girlfriend is moving to America with you. How come stability is your goal all of a sudden when you’ve always higlighted that you can’t do stability now that you’re moving abroad and don’t know what happens there and after? I guess you just lied to me from the beginning and never even thought of me as a potential girlfriend. Life seems to be disappointments one after another for me. I’m so jealous someone else gets to have you after you told me I would be perfect for you if you ever wanted to have a relationship knowing that that is exactly what I dream of.
Him: I’ve frequently said to you, and also to my friends, that one of the things that impressed me most about you is how great you are communicating directly and clearly and cutting through fluff. Which is why I feel so surprised by this. Maybe I am especially ignorant and blind, but I never understood from our conversations that you were saying that you would want me to love you. I took the hard no and boundaries you set as a clear communication that you sought only casual benefits from our connection. You were very upfront about other partners and experiences, and when you texted to say you had started a relationship and wanted to stop our meetings as a result, whilst I was sad to hear that, I accepted that as it was fair given the basis of what we had established. All of this kept me in the understanding that we were casual only. It’s gutting because not a single part of me would want to cause you pain and distress. I really loved our meetings because they felt so clear and without unsaid thoughts. We’ve never argued about anything in all the time of knowing each other so I just don’t know how to feel now. You did say that you wanted a relationship but it was always, at least as I understood it, to my perspective that I wasn’t even a consideration to that. Things are very early stage but it is someone who has expressed an interest to move abroad and has no family, commitments or career ties to Finland. So it’s unsure and risky, but plausible, but of course perhaps just a setup for failure. Stability was not the goal, happiness was, and I guess I am now trying to see if stability is a route to it after it presented itself and made me feel pretty happy. I really like you, and maybe I am colossally fumbling this whole thing causing pain and problems through ignorance, but I can assure you I didn’t lie to you and would have approached things differently if I had known this would be a cause of disappointment and anger.
Me: Ofc I didn’t tell you I seriously like you. You made it very clear that you’re not staying in Finland. I have a 7-year-old child here so I’m not moving abroad. When we first met you said you’re probably moving to America in a year or so. I’ve twice had a relationship with someone who after a few months told me he’s not staying in Finland. I’m direct and clear but not stupid enough to make the same mistake three times. I’ve thought the minute you say you want stability and have decided to stay in Finland I’ll ask you to have a date with me. You never did. The hard no and boundaries I set between us were there to protect my soul that’s been hurt enough times already. I’ve been upfront about other partners because I’ve been hoping that would make you feel jealous and because I thought you were curious and it didn’t bother you because you weren’t interested in a relationship in general. Furthermore, as I recall you’re not even sure if you want to have kids or not or at least family life isn’t a current interest of yours. Again, I have a kid. Seems like your new girlfriend suits your situation way better than me when she’s childless and ready to move abroad. I did not want to have a relationship with a person that would leave me as soon as his employer bought him a ticket to America. I wanted to have a relationship with you. If I had told you that we couldn’t have kept on having just sex dates. At least for me we have to be on a same page and that’s what we were when you told me you don’t want to start a relationship with anyone when you’re leaving the country anytime now. You did say that if you wanted to have a relationship in Finland it would be with me. Now you have a relationship but it’s not with me. Anyway I sincerely hope you are happy. Thank you for our moments together. You’re a beautiful person.
2 päivää myöhemmin:
Me: Did I write something stupid or offensive?
Him: I’m sorry, I’m a bit just taken aback that the connection in my life that I thought was probably the most straight forward and best communicated, actually had a lot unsaid. But me too, I had really great times with you, really enjoyed your company and have heaps of respect for you. I’m sorry all the misunderstanding took place.
Me: Well I hope you can understand my perspective and reasoning behind not telling you about my hopes of you changing your mind about moving abroad. I hope you would comment on my message. I’d really like to hear your view about our different life situations (vs you and your new girlfriend). Ofc I didn’t want to be an obstacle for you to fulfill your dream of living in America and be the only reason for you to stay here. It should’ve been your initiative if it was meant to be.
Seuraavana päivänä
Me: Ok, I’ll ask directly if that would be a better way to get answers: Can you understand my perspective and reasoning? What’s your view about our different life situations? Would you like to lose your dreams for a relationship? Do you find me fake and dishonest? I don’t think protecting my soul and mind is dishonesty.
Him: Respectfully I don’t want to answer these questions, they feel weighted in hurt feelings, I have taken in all you said from what you wrote and hear you, and don’t disregard your experiences at all, and hopefully I also explained my experience and perspective well enough.
Me: No you didn’t. I’m surprised you want to end this in bad feelings. I thought you’re a person who would like to clear the air before closing the case.
Him: What is this based on?
Me: That you won’t answer my questions. That you say questions that are weighted in hurt feelings are not worth answering. That you rather leave me hanging with questions unanswered and even claim that’s respectful. It’s not, it’s mean and arrogant. How can you say you don’t disregard my experiences when you do exactly that by not answering my questions.
4 päivää myöhemmin
Me: Actions talk louder than words so it feels I was meaningless to you after all. I guess we wouldn’t be compatible anyway because I like to talk things through and apparently you rather escape.
Ja sitten yksinäisyyden hiljaisuus.
